OPERATION
QUICK
FLIP
-
Operation Quick Flip is designed
to show that federal law
enforcement recognizes the
mortgage fraud threat. The
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Criminal Investigative Division
(CID), the Department of Housing
and Urban Development (HUD)
Office of the Inspector General
(OIG), the United States Postal
Inspection Service (USPS), the
Internal Revenue Service (IRS),
and the Department of Justice
(DOJ) have participated in this
case round-up to provide
information to the public
regarding the federal
government's efforts to combat
mortgage fraud. The federal
agencies involved are targeting
mortgage fraud groups in order to
disrupt and dismantle them
permanently.
-
Mortgage Fraud is one of the
fastest growing white collar
crimes in the United States.
Mortgage Fraud is defined as a
material misstatement,
misrepresentation, or omission
relied upon by an underwriter or
lender to fund, purchase, or
insure a loan.
-
There are two types of Mortgage
Fraud: fraud for property and
fraud for profit. Fraud for
Property, also known as Fraud for
Housing, usually involves the
borrower as the perpetrator on a
single loan. The borrower makes a
few misrepresentations, usually
regarding income, personal debt,
and property value or there are
down payment problems. The
borrower wants the property and
intends to repay the loan.
Sometimes industry professionals
are involved in coaching the
borrower so that they qualify.
Fraud for Property/Housing
accounts for 20 percent of all
fraud.
-
Fraud for Profit involves
industry professionals. There are
generally multiple loan
transactions with several
financial institutions involved.
These frauds include numerous
gross misrepresentations
including: income is overstated,
assets are overstated, collateral
is overstated, the length of
employment is overstated or
fictitious employment is
reported, and employment is
backstopped by co-conspirators.
The borrower's debts are not
fully disclosed, nor is the
borrower's credit history, which
is often altered. Often, the
borrower assumes the identity of
another person (straw buyer). The
borrower states he intends to use
the property for occupancy when
he/she intends to use the
property for rental income, or is
purchasing the property for
another party (nominee).
Appraisals almost always list the
property as owner-occupied. Down
payments do not exist or are
borrowed and disguised with a
fraudulent gift letter. The
property value is inflated
(faulty appraisal) to increase
the sales value to make up for no
down payment and to generate cash
proceeds in fraud for
profit.
-
-
Backward
Applications: After
identifying a property to
purchase, a borrower
customizes his/her income to
meet the loan
criteria.
-
-
Air Loans:
These are non-existent
property loans where there is
usually no collateral. An
example would be where a
broker invents borrowers and
properties, establishes
accounts for payments and
maintains custodial accounts
for escrows. They may set up
an office with a bank of
telephones, each one used as
the employer, appraiser,
credit agency, etc. for
verification purposes.
-
-
Silent
Seconds: The buyer
of a property borrows the
down payment from the seller
through the issuance of a
non-disclosed second
mortgage. The primary lender
believes the borrower has
invested his own money in the
down payment, when in fact,
it is borrowed. The second
mortgage may not be recorded
to further conceal its status
from the primary
lender.
-
-
Nominee
Loans: The identity
of the borrower is concealed
through the use of a nominee
who allows the borrower to
use the nominee's name and
credit history to apply for a
loan.
-
-
Property
Flips: Property is
purchased, falsely appraised
at a higher value, and then
quickly sold. What makes
property flipping illegal is
that the appraisal
information is fraudulent.
The schemes typically involve
fraudulent appraisals,
doctored loan documents, and
inflation of the buyer’s
income.
-
-
Foreclosure
schemes: The subject
identifies homeowners who are
at risk of defaulting on
loans or whose houses are
already in foreclosure.
Subjects mislead the
homeowners into believing
that they can save their
homes in exchange for a
transfer of the deed and
up-front fees. The subject
profits from these schemes by
re-mortgaging the property or
pocketing the fees paid by
the homeowner.
-
-
Equity
Skimming: An
investor may use a straw
buyer, false income
documents, and false credit
reports to obtain a mortgage
loan in the straw buyer's
name. Subsequent to closing,
the straw buyer signs the
property over to the investor
in a quit claim deed which
relinquishes all rights to
the property and provides no
guaranty to title. The
investor does not make any
mortgage payments and rents
the property until
foreclosure takes place
several months later.
-
Federal law enforcement is
working with state and local law
enforcement, regulators, and the
financial institution industry to
combat the problem.
-
OFHEO (Office of Federal
Housing Enterprise Oversight)
has passed a regulation
requiring Freddie Mac and
Fannie Mae to report
suspicious mortgage fraud
activity on a Mortgage
Incident Notice (MFIN).
-
FBI, OFHEO, and FinCEN
(Financial Crimes Enforcement
Network) are working to
establish a reporting device
similar to the banking
industry's Suspicious
Activity Report. This is in
progress, but will likely
take some time as regulations
and possibly legislation will
have to be passed.
-
The FBI, HUD-OIG, USPS, and
IRS conduct criminal
investigations into Mortgage
Fraud Activity with a goal of
disrupting and dismantling
mortgage fraud rings. We
strongly support joint
investigations to effectively
utilize all of our limited
resources while strengthening
investigations by tapping
into everyone's
expertise.
-
From July 5, 2005, until October
27, 2005, the FBI, HUD-OIG, USPS,
IRS, in coordination with the
DOJ, indicted 156 mortgage fraud
subjects. A total of 81 arrests
were made. A total of 89
convictions were obtained, and 60
subjects were sentenced during
this time frame.
-
The combined loss to the
industry by the
above-subjects is
$606,830,604.
-
In fiscal year 2005, the
following stats are
available:
-
21,994 SARs were filed (up
from 17,127 in Fiscal Year
2004).
-
721 pending FBI Mortgage
Fraud cases (up from 534 in
Fiscal Year 2004).
-
1,020 pending HUD-OIG
Mortgage Fraud cases (up from
920 in Fiscal Year
2004).
-
206 FBI
indictments/informations
(down from 241 in Fiscal Year
2004).
-
170 FBI convictions
(consistent with 172
convictions in Fiscal Year
2004)
-
$1,014,000,000 (FBI) reported
loss (up from $429,000,000 in
Fiscal Year 2004).
-
Top ten hot spots for Mortgage
Fraud activity in 2003 (per
capita): California, Nevada,
Utah, Colorado, Missouri,
Illinois, Michigan, South
Carolina, Georgia, and
Florida.
-
Top ten hot spots for Mortgage
Fraud activity in 2004 (per
capita): California, Nevada,
Utah, Arizona, Colorado,
Missouri, Illinois, Maryland,
Georgia, and Florida
|
|
|
2 Comments
Click here to sign up now.